Red and blue fish cut-out cookies iced in bold stripes

Specialty Cookies Buffalo NY

Rainbow striped pinata cut-out cookies decorated with royal icing

Cookies built around your theme

Send us the invitation and we will match it, right down to the icing palette.

Our cut-out cookies are rolled, cut, baked and hand piped in the bakery, then flooded with royal icing and left to set properly so the detail holds. Baby showers, first birthdays, retirements, corporate launches, holidays: if there is a theme, there is a cookie for it.

Favors and packaging

We can wrap cookies individually in cellophane and finish them with ribbon in your colors, which makes them work as favors on a place setting or in a gift bag. It is one of the things customers come back for most often.

The one thing we ship

Once royal icing is fully set, a cut-out cookie travels well and keeps for well over a week in a sealed container. That makes cut-out cookies the only item on our menu we are able to ship. Everything else is pickup at the bakery.

Dietary options

The daily case regularly carries gluten-free, vegan and vegan gluten-free items. For a large custom cookie order with a dietary requirement, call ahead so we can confirm what will work. Everything is made in a facility that also handles nuts, peanuts, soy, dairy, eggs and gluten.

How ordering works

Decorated cookie orders need at least 10 days, and longer if the shape needs a cutter we do not already carry. Orders are paid in full when placed. Pricing depends on size, the number of icing colors and how much detail the design carries, so send us your idea for a quote.

Email us for a cookie quote Cookie gallery

Good to know

Cookie ordering questions

What is the minimum notice for a decorated cookie order?

Cut-out and decorated cookie orders need at least 10 days. Themed orders with custom cutters may need longer.

Can you ship cookies?

Cut-out cookies are the only item we ship. Everything else on the menu is pickup only.

Can you match cookies to a party theme or invitation?

Yes. Send us the colors, the theme or a photo of the invitation and we will design cut-out cookies to match, right down to the icing palette.

Do you individually wrap cookies for favors?

We can wrap cookies individually and finish them with ribbon so they work as shower, wedding or party favors.

Are there gluten-free or vegan cookie options?

The daily case regularly includes gluten-free, vegan and vegan gluten-free items. For a large custom order with a dietary requirement, call ahead so we can confirm what is possible.

Still have a question? Call the bakery on 716-436-3001 during open hours.